Page 16 of 18
Fibre Channel: Why another interface?
March 2001
The following table compares the major characteristics of SCSI bus,
Ethernet, and Fibre Channel technologies.
The data storage challenge
Many companies meet their initial storage needs by using a SCSI bus to
connect a tape drive or a library to each server. As the amount of data and
number of servers increases, this simple one-to-one approach becomes
unmanageable. Often, the next step is to attach the tape drives or library to
a dedicated backup server. Unfortunately, moving the large volumes of
data over the network to the backup server seriously degrades both
backup and overall system performance. In todays demanding
environment, companies cannot afford the reduced network performance
or schedule sufficient network down time to allow for adequate data
protection.
One of the most promising solutions to this data storage dilemma is the
Storage Area Network (SAN), a separate network dedicated to
data-storage traffic. This dedicated network can move huge amounts of
data quickly to and from storage without interrupting data availability or
network performance. Fibre Channels numerous advantages over
traditional bus or network connections make it ideally suited for use in
SANs. Because it was specifically designed for high-speed data transfer,
Fibre Channel is the interface technology of choice for providing flexible,
reliable, high-performance sharing of data storage and backup resources
among multiple servers.
SCSI
Ethernet
Fibre Channel
Topology
Daisy chain
Point-to-point, switched fabric
Point-to-point, arbitrated loop,
switched fabric
Current maximum
data transfer rate
20 MB/sec (SCSI-2)
160 MB/sec (SCSI-3)
1.25 to 12.5 MB/sec
(10/100 BaseT Ethernet)
125 MB/sec (Gigabit Ethernet)a
aGigabit Ethernet is a new 1000 BaseT Ethernet implementation intended to provide high-speed data transfer capability for local area and
wide area networks.
200 MB/sec
Maximum distance
between devices
6 meters, single-ended,
25 meters, differential
30 meters (copper)
10 to 30 kilometers (fiber optic)
30 meters (copper)
10 to 30 kilometers (fiber optic)
Supported protocols
SCSI
SCSI, IP, HIPPI, many others
SCSI, IP, HIPPI, many others
Maximum number of
attached devices
8 (SCSI-1)
16 (SCSI-2, SCSI-3)
unlimited
127 (single arbitrated loop)
16 million (switched fabric)
Comparison of SCSI, Ethernet, and Fibre Channel
Companies today face the
challenge of meeting 24/7/365
data availability requirements
while at the same time
protecting their valuable data
with regularly scheduled
backups.
p1
p2
p3
p4
p5
p6
p7
p8
p9
p10
p11
p12
p13
p14
p15
p16
p17
p18